What they mentioned in 2016 means nothing right this moment now that they will get a brand new, conservative Supreme Courtroom justice.
What they will do, they are going to do. Simply as it’s a must to have a look at the letter of what is potential to conclude they will have a brand new Supreme Courtroom justice on the bench earlier than or quickly after Election Day, you also needs to look to the letter of what is potential relating to the presidential election itself.
The letter of what is potential underneath the legislation in an in depth election is extraordinarily ambiguous, which is sufficient to lead anybody down any variety of maddening rabbit holes.
These are the fringiest nightmare situations. However in a time when Trump’s keen to name the nationwide guard to US cities, they’re price contemplating.
The obvious factor to recollect, as college students of American historical past and readers of this text and everybody who voted for Hillary Clinton is aware of, is that the Electoral School picks the President.
And the letter of the legislation can be that, in response to the Supreme Courtroom in Bush v. Gore, states have the ability to take electoral votes again from the voters if there is a query in regards to the end result, as they primarily did in Florida in 2000 after they barred the state from conducting a recount in order that it might meet a deadline.
For example, the Structure says a brand new President should take the oath of workplace on January 20.
As a way to make that occur, a separate US legislation — the Electoral Rely Act — set a timetable for counting Electoral School votes. That is the timetable cited by the Courtroom in Bush v. Gore. And it suggests disputes about outcomes have to be settled 35 days after Election Day.
Key dates this 12 months, in response to Biskupic:
- December 8, when states should decide their election outcomes
- December 14, when state electors truly convene within the states to forged their votes for president and vice chairman
Key phrase: “protected harbor.” Biskupic once more: That first deadline, six days earlier than the Electoral School meets, is named a “protected harbor” date, when all court docket challenges needs to be resolved. If states certify their outcomes by then, their validity have to be accepted by Congress.
Vote counting within the pandemic election, with a crush of mail-in ballots is already speculated to take for much longer than typical. Trump has already mentioned, repeatedly, that in his view solely what’s recognized on Election Night time issues. This isn’t true, in fact, however he’ll preserve saying it.
Disputes over state outcomes: In a 12 months when the President has already repeatedly alleged fraud, albeit with none proof, delays might be exploited.
“The State, in fact, after granting the franchise within the particular context of Article II, can take again the ability to nominate electors,” the late Justice Antonin Scalia wrote in Bush v. Gore.
And Gellman talks on the document to Republican officers within the swing state of Pennsylvania who say they’ve not less than considerably thought of how the state legislature might appoint electors within the absence of a transparent Election Night time victory.