5 judges thought of the case, figuring out that Subway bread has an excessive amount of sugar in it to be a part of this class, and is subsequently topic to the next tax.
“The bread equipped by Subway in its heated sandwiches has a sugar content material of 10% of the load of the flour included within the dough,” Justice Donal O’Donnell mentioned when delivering the judgment.
Underneath Eire’s Tax Act 1972, the sugar content material mustn’t exceed 2% of the load of flour within the dough.
O’Donnell rejected arguments from the franchisee, Bookfinders Ltd, and dominated that “the ensuing product falls outdoors the definition of ‘bread’ for the needs of the Act.”
A spokesperson for Subway mentioned in a press release to CNN: “Subway’s bread is, in fact, bread. Now we have been baking recent bread in our eating places for greater than three many years and our friends return every day for sandwiches made on bread that smells nearly as good because it tastes.”
CNN has contacted Bookfinders Ltd for remark.
Subway is the world’s largest quick meals chain. There are 145 Subway areas in Eire, in accordance with the corporate web site, with greater than 22,000 in the US and round 38,000 worldwide.
In 2018, the chain closed greater than 1,000 areas within the US as a part of a downsizing effort after struggling to adapt to extra health-conscious, tech-savvy prospects.
It has tried to adapt to shifting shopper preferences by trialing the meatless Past Meatball sub in September 2019, which used plant-based protein.
The trial meant Subway joined a rising variety of quick meals chains testing out menu gadgets that includes meat substitutes.